Lara E. Montecalvo

Active United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit Biden · 2022 3 years on the bench
Court
United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit
Class
Active
Appointed by
President Joseph Biden
Commissioned
September 20, 2022
Years of service
3 years on the bench
Official biography
Court biography →

Authored opinions (34 recorded, Jun 2025–Sep 2026)

Flanagan v. Fresenius Medical Care Holdings, Inc. — Jun 27, 2025 Central Maine Power Company v. ME Comm'n on Gov't Ethics and Election Practices — Jul 11, 2025 Boniface v. Viliena — Jul 21, 2025 US v. Rivera-Rivera — Jul 25, 2025 Doe v. University of Massachusetts — Jul 25, 2025 Lavigne v. Great Salt Bay Community School Board — Jul 28, 2025 McKenna v. Maine Dep't of Health and Human Services — Aug 18, 2025 Suny v. KCP Advisory Group, LLC — Aug 19, 2025 Foss v. Eastern States Exposition — Aug 21, 2025 BI 40 LLC v. Ironshore Specialty Insurance Company — Aug 25, 2025 Bernitz v. USAble Life — Aug 27, 2025 Perales-Munoz v. US — Sep 2, 2025 Federated Mutual Insurance Company v. Peterson's Oil Service, Inc. — Sep 8, 2025 US v. Paredes — Oct 24, 2025 US v. Castillo — Oct 24, 2025 Dor v. Bondi — Dec 1, 2025 US v. Yu — Dec 11, 2025 Donovan v. Massachusetts Parole Board — Dec 23, 2025 Khanal v. Bondi — Feb 18, 2026 US v. Figueroa — Mar 17, 2026 Holland v. Elevance Health, Inc. — Mar 27, 2026 Kendell Seafood Imports, Inc. v. Mark Foods, LLC — Mar 27, 2026 US v. Giang — Apr 22, 2026 US v. Pimental — May 20, 2026 Santos-Pagan v. Bayamon Medical Center — Jun 11, 2026 US v. da Conceicao-Level — Jun 16, 2026 US v. Omoruyi — Jul 15, 2026 US v. Irizarry-Irizarry — Jul 24, 2026 Guerrero Orellana v. Moniz — Aug 13, 2026 5-Star General Store v. American Express Company — Aug 19, 2026 US v. Bourget — Aug 21, 2026 Galakatos v. Marsh & McLennan Companies, Inc. — Aug 21, 2026 de la Fuente Diaz v. Gonzalez Colon — Sep 1, 2026 US v. Pena de la Cruz — Sep 11, 2026 2025 2026

Each mark is a majority opinion this judge wrote; hover for the case (hollow marks were later vacated). The timeline begins with the earliest opinion in the database (June 2025), not the judge’s first day on the bench; earlier opinions may predate it.

Judge Lara Montecalvo received her commission on September 20, 2022, after being nominated by President Biden to fill the seat vacated following the assumption of senior status by Judge O. Rogeriee Thompson.

Judge Montecalvo served for over fifteen years as an assistant public defender in the Rhode Island Public Defender’s Office and in 2020 became the Rhode Island Public Defender, a role she held until her appointment to the First Circuit. She is a graduate of Boston College Law School and Swarthmore College.

Judge Montecalvo’s Judicial Nominee Questionnaire

Judicial activity

Drawn from 392 tagged published First Circuit opinions. Consolidated cases are counted once.

Published cases decided
118
In majority
118
Wrote majority
34
Maj. rate
100%
Court average: 99%
Concurrences
0
Concur. in J.
0
Dissents
0
Partial diss.
0

Most frequent panel partners

Seth R. Aframe 39 times in the majority together
William J. Kayatta, Jr. 33 times in the majority together
O. Rogeriee Thompson 31 times in the majority together
Gustavo A. Gelpí 26 times in the majority together
Sandra L. Lynch 21 times in the majority together
David J. Barron 20 times in the majority together

Notable opinions authored

Sep 4, 2025 Stay pending appeal — Denied · joined majority

Orr v. Trump

May 20, 2026 Injunction pending appeal — Denied · joined majority

In re Motion to Quash Admin. Subpoena to RI Hosp.

Recent opinions authored