Know Your Panel
Thursday, March 6, 2025
9:30 am San Juan—José V. Toledo Federal Building
6 arguments · Panel: Gelpí, Lipez, and Rikelman
Per the court’s argument calendar as of September 3, 2026. Panels and schedules can change—confirm with the clerk’s office.
6 of 6 cases decided · median 164 days from argument. The record of this sitting is complete.
The panel
Recent authored opinions
- US v. Gonzalez (Sep 4, 2026) Vac’d in part
- Kyick Holdings, LLC v. Bessent (Aug 17, 2026) Aff’d
- Rodriguez-Cotto v. Gonzalez-Colon (Aug 4, 2026) Aff’d
Recent arguments before this judge
- United States v. Robert Monteiro (audio, Sep 10)
- Codan Forsikring A/S v. Sean Bogus, et al. (audio, Sep 10)
Kermit V. Lipez Senior Judge
Recent authored opinions
- Savage v. City of Springfield (Sep 16, 2026) Aff’d
- Giguere v. Tardif (Aug 17, 2026) Aff’d
- Calvary Chapel Belfast v. University of Maine System (Jun 30, 2026) Aff’d
Recent arguments before this judge
- John Epstein v. Bruce Furniture, Inc. (audio, May 6)
- United States v. Juan Carlos Reynoso (audio, May 6)
Recent authored opinions
- US v. Levasseur (Sep 16, 2026) Aff’d
- Hurley v. Curtis (Aug 21, 2026) Aff’d
- US v. Cooper (Aug 6, 2026) Vac’d in part
Recent arguments before this judge
- United States v. Jayson Pastrana-Roman (audio, Sep 16)
- Kayo Felipe Costa Dondoni, et al. v. Todd Blanche (audio, Sep 16)
The docket—order of call
| Case | Docket | Audio | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States v. Héctor Maldonado-Maldonado Appellant: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 22-1650 | Listen | Apr 11, 2025 Vac’d |
| United States v. Crystall Kareem Robles-López Appellant: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 23-1587 | Listen | Mar 4, 2026 Vac’d |
| Northwestern Selecta, Inc. v. Ramón González-Beiró, et al. Appellants: 15 min. Appellee: 15 min. | 23-1657 | Listen | Jul 17, 2025 Aff’d |
| Erasto Román Mercado v. Hyannis Air Service, Inc. Appellant: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 23-1744 | Listen | Sep 22, 2025 Vac’d |
| United States v. Antonio Casillas-Montero Appellant: 15 min. Appellee: 15 min. | 23-1859 | Listen | Sep 16, 2025 Aff’d |
| Coco Rico, LLC v. Universal Insurance Company Appellant/Cross-Appellee: 15 min. Appellee/Cross-Appellant: 15 min. | 24-1328 24-1335 |
Listen | Jun 20, 2025 Rev’d in part |