Know Your Panel
Friday, March 7, 2025
9:30 am San Juan—José V. Toledo Federal Building
5 arguments · Panel: Barron, Lipez, and Thompson
Per the court’s argument calendar as of September 3, 2026. Panels and schedules can change—confirm with the clerk’s office.
5 of 5 cases decided · median 109 days from argument. The record of this sitting is complete.
The panel
This panel has sat together in 1 prior sitting in this site’s records, most recently May 2025.
David J. Barron Chief Judge
Recent authored opinions
- Citation Insurance Company v. Broan-NuTone LLC (Aug 28, 2026) Aff’d
- US v. Reynoso (Aug 24, 2026) Aff’d
- Urena v. Travelers Casualty and Surety Co. of America (Aug 11, 2026) Aff’d
Recent arguments before this judge
- United States v. Robert Monteiro (audio, Sep 10)
- Codan Forsikring A/S v. Sean Bogus, et al. (audio, Sep 10)
Kermit V. Lipez Senior Judge
Recent authored opinions
- Savage v. City of Springfield (Sep 16, 2026) Aff’d
- Giguere v. Tardif (Aug 17, 2026) Aff’d
- Calvary Chapel Belfast v. University of Maine System (Jun 30, 2026) Aff’d
Recent arguments before this judge
- John Epstein v. Bruce Furniture, Inc. (audio, May 6)
- United States v. Juan Carlos Reynoso (audio, May 6)
O. Rogeriee Thompson Senior Judge
Recent authored opinions
- Doe v. Smith (Sep 15, 2026) Aff’d
- Instituto Medico del Norte, Inc. v. Greengift Capital, LLC (Sep 2, 2026) Vac’d
- McDonald v. US (Aug 28, 2026) Denied in part
Recent arguments before this judge
- Richard Weed v. United States (audio, Sep 15)
- Olga Ximena Astudillo-Villanueva, et al. v. Todd Blanche (audio, Sep 15)
The docket—order of call
| Case | Docket | Audio | Decision |
|---|---|---|---|
| United States v. José Luis Meléndez-Rivera Appellant: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 22-1665 | Listen | Jun 4, 2025 Aff’d |
| Yemal Calderón-Amézquita v. Dr. Víctor Rivera-Cruz, et al. Appellant: 10 min. Appellees: 10 min. | 23-1091 | Listen | Oct 30, 2025 Vac’d in part |
| United States v. Sixto Jorge Díaz-Colón Appellant: 15 min. Appellee: 15 min. | 23-1692 | Listen | Dec 22, 2025 Aff’d |
| United States v. Xavier O. Maldonado-Negroni Appellant: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 23-1768 | Listen | Jun 24, 2025 Vac’d |
| Luis Feliciano-Muñoz, et al. v. Fred J. Rebarber-Ocasio Appellants: 10 min. Appellee: 10 min. | 24-1122 | Listen | Apr 23, 2025 Aff’d |